Unit 4, lesson 44

Samples, Populations and Bias

How a random sample lets you estimate a population proportion or mean, why the estimate is never exact, and how the way a sample is chosen limits whom the results describe.

  • Theory part 87
  • Practice part 88
  • Statistical Reasoning

Theory, part 87

Practice, part 88

A school with 1,2001{,}200 students wants to know how many would use a quiet study room after classes. Asking every student takes weeks. Asking 8080 students takes an afternoon, and if those 8080 are chosen well, their answers give a good estimate for the whole school. If they are chosen badly, say only students already in the library, the estimate can be far off no matter how carefully the numbers are worked out. SAT questions on sampling ask what a sample can tell you and about whom.

Key terms

Population

Definition The population of a study is the entire group of individuals, people or objects, that the study wants to draw conclusions about. A number that describes the whole population, such as the proportion of all students who would use the room or the mean height of all trees in a forest, is a parameter. A parameter is usually unknown, because measuring every member is too costly or impossible.

In plain words The population is everyone the question is really about.

Example In the study room survey the population is all 1,2001{,}200 students at the school. The parameter of interest is the proportion of those 1,2001{,}200 students who would use the room. Students at other schools are not part of this population.

Sample

Definition A sample is a subset of the population whose members are actually measured or asked. A number computed from the sample, such as a sample proportion or a sample mean, is a statistic, and it is used to estimate the matching population parameter.

In plain words The sample is the part of the population you actually hear from. You learn about the whole by looking at the part.

Example The 8080 students who answer the study room question form the sample. If 2828 of them say they would use the room, the statistic 2880\frac{28}{80} describes these 8080 students exactly and describes the school only approximately.

Random sample

Definition A random sample is a sample chosen by a chance process from the population. In a simple random sample of size nn, every possible group of nn members of the population has the same chance of being the sample, so in particular every member has the same chance of being chosen. Random selection removes the influence of the person choosing, but it does not remove sampling variation. Two random samples from the same population usually give different statistics, and neither one is exactly the parameter.

In plain words Let chance decide who is asked, for example by drawing names from a complete list. The results still wobble from sample to sample, but they do not lean in one direction on purpose or by habit.

Example The school numbers its students from 11 to 1,2001{,}200 and uses a random number generator to pick 8080 different numbers. That is a simple random sample. A second random draw might give 2525 or 3131 students who would use the room instead of 2828. How large that wobble tends to be is the subject of Margin of Error and Interpreting Estimates.

Sample proportion

Definition If xx members of a sample of size nn have a certain property, the sample proportion is

p^=xn.\hat{p} = \frac{x}{n}.

When the sample is a random sample from a population of size NN, the value p^\hat{p} estimates the population proportion pp, and p^⋅N\hat{p} \cdot N estimates the number of population members with the property. In the same way the mean of a random sample estimates the population mean. These are estimates, not the exact population values.

In plain words Find the fraction in the sample, then scale it up to the population. Say “about” when you report the result.

Example For the study room survey,

p^=2880=0.35,\hat{p} = \frac{28}{80} = 0.35,

so the best estimate is that about 0.35⋅1200=4200.35 \cdot 1200 = 420 students would use the room. The true count could be somewhat higher or lower. A sample mean works the same way. A random sample of 4040 of the 2,5002{,}500 households in a town has a mean of 2.62.6 people per household, so the town’s mean household size is estimated as about 2.62.6 and its total number of people living in households as about 2.6⋅2500=65002.6 \cdot 2500 = 6500.

Representative sample

Definition A sample is representative of a population when the sample’s makeup, in the features that matter for the question, is close to the population’s makeup. Random sampling from the whole population is the standard way to make a representative sample likely. Results from a sample generalize only to the population it was drawn from, and not automatically to any larger or different group.

In plain words A representative sample looks like a small copy of the population. A sample drawn from one group speaks for that group and no other.

Example A random sample of 8080 students from the full list of the school can represent the school. A random sample of 8080 students from the list of seniors can represent the seniors only. Its results may say little about ninth graders, who may stay after classes more or less often, and nothing at all about students at another school.

Selection bias

Definition Selection bias is a systematic error that comes from the way a sample is chosen, when some members of the population are much more or less likely than others to end up in the sample, so that the sample tends to differ from the population in a predictable direction. Two common sources are convenience samples, made of members who are easy to reach, and voluntary response samples, made of members who choose to take part. A larger sample chosen the same biased way does not fix selection bias.

In plain words If the way you pick people leaves out a part of the population, or favors one part, the results lean that way. Asking more people the same way just repeats the lean.

Example Suppose the school surveys only students it finds in the library after classes. Those students already like to study after school, so the share who would use a study room is likely to be higher than in the whole school, and the students who leave right after the last bell are excluded completely. An online poll that students can answer if they want has the same kind of problem, since students with strong opinions are more likely to respond. The random sample drawn from the full list avoids both problems.

Check yourself

  1. A researcher selects 200200 dog owners at random from the list of all licensed dog owners in a city and finds that 6262 percent of them walk their dog at least twice a day. To which group can the result most reasonably be generalized? (A) All residents of the city (B) All licensed dog owners in the city (C) All dog owners in the country (D) Only the 200200 dog owners who were surveyed
Show the answer

The correct choice is (B). The sample was drawn at random from the licensed dog owners of the city, so that is the population it represents. Choice (A) includes people who own no dog. Choice (C) goes beyond the population that was sampled. Choice (D) is too narrow, since a random sample is meant to support an estimate for its population.

  1. A park has 900900 trees. A random sample of 6060 of them is inspected, and 1414 of the sampled trees show signs of a fungus. Based on the sample, what is the best estimate of the number of trees in the park that show signs of the fungus?
Show the answer

The answer is 210210. The sample proportion is 1460\frac{14}{60}, and

1460⋅900=210.\frac{14}{60} \cdot 900 = 210.

This is an estimate. The actual number of affected trees in the park may differ somewhat.

  1. A town wants to estimate the proportion of its adult residents who support a new bus route. Which method is most likely to produce a representative sample? (A) Asking 300300 riders at the busiest bus stop one morning (B) Posting a survey online and using the first 300300 responses (C) Selecting 300300 adults at random from a complete list of the town’s adult residents (D) Asking 300300 adults who attend a meeting about the bus route
Show the answer

The correct choice is (C). It is the only method in which every adult resident has the same chance of being chosen. Choice (A) is a convenience sample of people who already ride the bus. Choices (B) and (D) rely on people who choose to respond or attend, who are likely to care more about the route than residents in general.

How this lesson connects